SpaceX's Starlink is already making waves in South Korea, and not necessarily in a good way. The satellite internet service, barely off the launchpad in the local market, is facing a barrage of criticism for how its availability map designates Dokdo, a set of islets long administered by South Korea. The map labels them as "Liancourt Rocks," a designation many find deeply problematic.
Starlink Map SHOCK: Did SpaceX Just Anger a Nation...
So, what's the big deal? Well, "Liancourt Rocks" is a name that stems from a French whaling ship that apparently sailed by the islets back in 1849. While technically neutral, its use ignores the established Korean name, Dokdo, and implicitly lends credence to alternative claims. As of Sunday, if you searched for either "Dokdo" or "Liancourt Rocks" on Starlink's map, you wouldn't actually get any service availability marker. A bit of a geographical dead end, it seems.
This whole thing kicked off just last week, coinciding with Starlink's launch of two home internet plans, priced at a not-insignificant 64,000 won ($43) and 87,000 won per month. You'd think they'd want to avoid controversy right out of the gate, but here we are.
Experts are pretty clear on this: using the French-derived name is just plain inaccurate and disrespectful of established naming conventions. "Dokdo is Dokdo — it is a proper noun," argues Seo Kyung-duk, a professor at Sungshin Women’s University. "Long before that French whaling ship ever spotted it, the islets were called Dokdo. It is not Takeshima (the name used by Japan), nor Liancourt Rocks.” That's a pretty strong statement, and I can see where he's coming from. It's about more than just a name; it's about sovereignty and historical recognition.
Professor Seo isn't just complaining; he's planning to take action. He intends to formally request that Starlink correct the labeling, and he's got a pile of evidence to back up his claim. Good for him. Sometimes, you have to fight for what's right, even if it's just a matter of getting a map to reflect reality.
Interestingly, this isn't the first time a major tech company has stumbled into this naming quagmire. Back in September, Seo also pointed out that Google Maps was using "Liancourt Rocks" in 42 countries. Google Maps, somewhat awkwardly, shows "Dokdo" within South Korea, but "Takeshima" to users in Japan. That's a delicate balancing act, and clearly, these tech giants are walking a tightrope trying to appease everyone. But perhaps, in this case, a little historical accuracy should take precedence over political sensitivities.
Comments
Please sign in with Google to post a comment
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!